As Peter visits Uncle Ben's grave, he is met by a forgotten ex-neighbor, Dave "Sully" Sullivan. While Sully is glad to meet Peter again, Peter is crestfallen thinking about how his uncle would think of him as Ben had a wife & stable career by the time he was Peter's current age. Hearing Peter's lamentations, Sully recalls how Ben and May were always helping their neighbors in their Forrest Hills community, but also how Ben was reflective on if he could have done more for May and Peter to give them a better home life. Hearing such a fact, Peter sadly focuses on events where his loved ones were let down by him, feeling if he should have been more attentive to his family and friends instead of his activities elsewhere. As Sully gets apologetic at getting Peter flustered, Peter finally recalls Sully as the neighborhood drunk who backslid each time Ben helped, leading to Ben moving Sully's wife and daughter out of town before Ben knocked him down one time when flushed. Sully acknowledges this, but affirms that he came to present his One-Year Sobriety chip to Ben's grave, having fought too hard to get sober yet worked through it with Ben's memory as motivation. Now sober, Sully reconciled with his daughter and met his grandson, happy at finally turning his life around and hoping it would've made Ben proud. Peter thanks the tearful Sully, and is grateful to Uncle Ben for his having been his father figure even if Ben never got rich or advanced in careers. Peter was just glad to have had Ben in his life, and is thankful that Sully for helping him remember the man Ben was. The two take their leave, with Sully inviting Peter to meet his daughter and grandson for her peach cobbler, as Peter accepts the invitation.